Two highly-rated VSC providers compared side by side. See which one offers better coverage, better pricing, and the better overall deal.
Get My Free Coverage Quote →CARCHEX has been in the vehicle protection industry since 1999 and is known for its long track record and wide range of plan options. Complete Auto Protect is a newer competitor that has quickly built a strong reputation for exclusionary coverage and competitive pricing. Both carry A+ BBB ratings. Here's how they compare on the details that actually matter.
Compare vehicle service contract options in 30 seconds. No obligation, no pressure.
Check My Coverage Options →| Category | CARCHEX | Complete Auto Protect |
|---|---|---|
| Years in business | 25+ years (est. 1999) | Growing provider, strong BBB |
| Coverage tiers | 5 plans (Titanium to Powertrain) | 5 plans (Silver to EV Exclusionary) |
| Exclusionary option | ✓ Titanium plan | ✓ Diamond plan |
| Claims handling | Third-party administrator | Direct pay to repair shop |
| Repair shop network | Any ASE-certified shop | Any ASE-certified shop |
| Deductible | $100 per visit | $100 per visit |
| Monthly cost range | $104–$200/month | $89–$175/month |
| Max mileage | Up to 250,000 miles | Up to 250,000 miles |
| BBB rating | A+ | A+ |
| Waiting period | 30 days / 1,000 miles | 30 days / 1,000 miles |
| Roadside assistance | ✓ Included | ✓ Included |
| EV coverage | Limited | ✓ Dedicated EV Exclusionary plan |
Complete Auto Protect wins on pricing and has a clear advantage on EV coverage. CARCHEX's 25-year track record is a meaningful advantage for drivers who prioritize company history. For most drivers comparing the two, Complete Auto Protect delivers better value per dollar — especially for high-mileage vehicles and EV owners.
Choose CARCHEX if company longevity matters to you, you've had a previous positive experience with them, or you want the security of working with one of the industry's most established providers. CARCHEX's 25+ year history is a genuine differentiator in an industry with many short-lived companies.
Choose Complete Auto Protect if you want the best price for comparable coverage, own an EV and need dedicated EV coverage, or prefer a more straightforward direct-pay claims process. Complete Auto Protect's pricing advantage is consistent across coverage tiers.
Compare vehicle service contract options in 30 seconds. No obligation, no pressure.
Check My Coverage Options →Is CARCHEX or Complete Auto Protect better?
Both are A+ BBB-rated providers with strong reputations. Complete Auto Protect offers better pricing; CARCHEX offers a longer company history. For value-focused buyers, Complete Auto Protect has the edge.
Which is cheaper — CARCHEX or Complete Auto Protect?
Complete Auto Protect is typically $15–$25/month less expensive for comparable coverage tiers, making it meaningfully cheaper over a multi-year contract.
Does CARCHEX or Complete Auto Protect have better EV coverage?
Complete Auto Protect has a dedicated EV Exclusionary plan specifically designed for electric vehicles. CARCHEX's EV coverage is more limited. For EV owners, Complete Auto Protect is the clear choice.
How long has CARCHEX been in business?
CARCHEX was founded in 1999 — making it one of the longest-running third-party VSC providers in the industry. This track record is one of its strongest selling points.
Can I use any mechanic with CARCHEX and Complete Auto Protect?
Yes. Both providers allow any ASE-certified repair facility nationwide, including dealerships. You're not restricted to a specific shop network.